The critics’
argument against the remodeling of the Seaholm Power Plant and surrounding
space is that it will detract from the special personality of Austin. As well
as this, they contend that, by ceasing to act as a concert venue, it diminishes
the value of Austin as the live music capital of the world. The plant has long
been present in the hearts of Austinites, its distinct red neon sign a memory
for many. If not, the local icon can be found in countless photographs that attempt
to capture the spirit of Austin through the sign. Seaholm’s importance as a
landmark, regardless of its lack of use, is widely recognized. Proposing its
demolition would be akin to suggesting that we destroy the University of Texas
Tower. This is why critics, myself included, believe that the power plant
should remain as it is and continue to host musicians and exhibitions alike in
order for people to be able to reflect upon a historical piece of architecture
while experiencing Austin’s distinct culture.
Most supporters
of the urbanization plan agree that it would be disgusting if the power plant
was to be entirely demolished. But they believe that it would be more
beneficial if the area where the plant is located were to transform into a
modern space where people will be able to interact and live. Their argument is
that this space has great potential to bring in revenue for the city without
changing an existing area. Many are especially excited about the announcement
of the addition of a Trader Joe’s in the Seaholm District. In addressing the
loss of the music scene at the power plant, some argue that the location of the
nearby venues Austin Music Hall and Austin City Limits Studio are sufficient in
providing a place for the Austin music to thrive.
No doubt the
subject of what demographics will be present in this new area must be addressed.
Unfortunately, I believe that the Seaholm District will come to be known as a
secluded area of town that belongs to the upper class. The new residencies are
targeted for the upper class, so now doubt the close by events will cater to
them for their convenience. The only consolation that can be found is that it
is not similar to the situation of gentrification in East Austin since there is
nobody currently living in the soon-to-be neighborhood. Still, we can predict
that there will be not much diversity to be seen in the Seaholm District.
No comments:
Post a Comment